Incident Reports

Locals obstruct temple rebuilding, demand participation

2017-01-24

Bagmati, Kathmandu, Kathmandu

Locals at Basatapur on Tuesday obstructed ongoing reconstruction work at the Trailokya Narayan Temple inside Kathmandu Durbar Square Area. The temple had collapsed in the April 2015 earthquake. Locals protested against the reconstruction work, accusing the Department of Archaeology (DoA) of keeping them in the dark about the work and excluding them from involvement in the reconstruction of the historic temple in their own locality. Construction company Prakritik-Sanu Suwal-LP JV, which has been carrying out the reconstruction work, closed off the area with corrugated iron sheets. Locals accuse the authorities of erecting the sheet fence so that the locals would not be able to know what was going on inside. They said this move forced them to padlock the boundary gate, demanding their direct involvement in the reconstruction. “In the past we were repeatedly told that reconstruction of the heritage sites in our locality would take place with our direct involvement but the DoA hasn’t bothered about our participation,” Deepak Shrestha, a priest at the temple, told Republica. “Heritage sites are our property. So, we blocked the reconstruction to ensure our involvement in the process.” The temple is one of the major historical monuments of Kathmandu Durbar Square, an area which is in the list of Kathmandu Valley World Heritage Sites. There are six other such monument zones inside the Valley. “Community involvement in heritage rebuilding has been practiced for long in this area and it has been a great experience for both locals as well as the construction authorities,” said Shrestha. “This time however, the DoA didn’t consult us at all.” The locals were irate also because the DoA didn’t offer a Kshyama Puja, the practice of worshipping the deities of the temple and offering an apology before touching the temple, which is the property of the deities. “We need to perform Kshyama Puja before touching the soil of the deities and we believe the deities will allow us to touch the ritual site only after performing the Puja,” he said. Ganapati Lal Shrestha, another local, claimed that officials at the DoA had earlier promised them there would be local participation during the reconstruction of the temple. “But we were taken by surprise when we saw that the reconstruction work had already started inside the fencing, without the knowledge of the locals.” He said that the step taken by the DoA has also generated doubts about the quality of the reconstruction. He further argued that local participation in heritage rebuilding would ensure the originality of heritage sites. “Involving the community in the reconstruction of heritage in the Bhaktapur Durbar Square Area, another monument zone in the Valley, has worked wonders and helped in completing the monuments in time,” he said. “The local community in Bhaktapur played a major role in the reconstruction of the ancient monuments there. We should also adopt the same policy.” Bhesh Narayan Dahal, director general at the DoA, said they will hold discussions with the locals and address the issue soon. The DoA had signed the contract with the company in June 2016 and the project cost is estimated at Rs 37.5 million. आफूहरूलाई थाहै नदिई पुनर्निर्माण सुरु गरेको भन्दै पुजारीसहित स्थानीयवासीले त्रैलोक्यनारायण (दस अवतार) मन्दिर पुनर्निर्माणमा रोक लगाएका छन् । ठेकेदारले जस्ताले बारेर बनाएको गेटमा उनीहरूले ताला लगाइदिएका छन् । ‘हाम्रो चासो र सरोकारको मन्दिर कसरी पुनर्निर्माण हुँदै छ भनेर हामीले पनि थाहा पाउनुपर्छ,’ दसअवतार मन्दिरका पुजारी दीपकप्रसाद श्रेष्ठले भने, ‘हामीले यस विषयमा धेरैपटक चासो दियौं । हामीलाई पनि सहभागी गराउनुस् भन्यौं । तर, टेरपुच्छर लगाएनन् । त्यही भएर यो कदम चाल्न बाध्य भयौं ।’ पुरातत्त्व विभागले यो मन्दिर पुनर्निर्माणका लागि ठेक्का दिइसकेको छ । ठेक्कामा दिँदा सम्पदा नष्ट हुन्छ भन्दै स्थानीयवासीले ज्यालामा काम दिन माग गर्दै आएका छन् । यसको ठेक्का पाकृतिक सानो सुवाल (जेभी) ले पाएको छ । गत भदौमा निर्माण सम्झौता भइसकेको छ । निर्माण सम्झौता भएको ६ महिनासम्म पनि पुनर्निर्माण सुरु भएको थिएन । पुरातत्त्व विभागका अनुसार २०७५ असोजमा निर्माण सम्पन्न गर्ने गरी ३ करोड ७५ लाख रुपैयाँमा निर्माण सम्झौता भएको हो । काम सुरु गरेको छैन भने पनि बार लगाएर काम थालेको भन्दै स्थानीयले विरोध गरेका हुन् । ‘सम्पदाको निर्माणमा संवेदनशील हुनुपर्छ,’ श्रेष्ठ भन्छन्, ‘तर कामदारले जथाभावी खन्दै गरेको देख्यौं । पुरातत्त्व बुझेको मान्छेको रोहबरमा काम हुनुपथ्र्यो ।’ पेलेर काम गर्न थालेपछि रोक्न बाध्य भएको स्थानीयवासी बताउँछन् । ‘ठेक्कामा गइसकेपछि यही मोडलमा कसरी काम गर्ने भनेर हामीले छलफल गरिरहेका थियौं,’ सम्पदा पुनर्निर्माणलगायत स्थानीय काममा जनसहभागिता जुटाउन गठन भएको कान्तिपुर विकास समितिका प्रवक्ता गणपतिलाल श्रेष्ठ भन्छन्, ‘तर स्थानीयवासीलाई पेलेरै लैजाने नीति पुरातत्त्व विभागले बनायो । सम्पदा बनाउने नाममा मास्ने षड्यन्त्र भइरहेको छ । हामी कुनै हालतमा पनि सम्पदा नासिन दिँदैनौं । अब वसन्तपुर क्षेत्रमा बन्ने कुनै पनि मठ मन्दिर, दरबार ठेक्कामा बन्न दिँदैनौं ।’ पुरातत्त्व विभागले भने मन्दिर बनाएको नभई पेटी मात्रै भत्काएको दाबी गरेको छ । ‘स्थानीयवासीलाई चित्त बुझाएरै काम अघि बढाउँछौं,’ पुरातत्त्व विभागअन्तर्गतको हनुमानढोका दरबार क्षेत्र संरक्षण कार्यालयका इन्जिनियर गोपाल झा भन्छन्, ‘सहमति गरी हामी निकासातिर जानुपर्छ ।’
Details and Impacts
Violent / Non-violent Nonviolent
Collective / Interpersonal Collective
Primary Form Gherau/Dharna (sit-in)/padlocking
Primary Cause Issues related to the delivery of government aid programs (e.g. earthquake rehab/recon)
Actor 1 - Number of people 25
Actor 1 - Affiliations Citizen/Individuals
Actor 1 - Youth unknown
Actor 2 - Number of people NA
Actor 2 - Affiliation (Target) Government and civil servants at central level
Actor 2 - Youth na
National/Online Media

0 Comments

Related Reports
Related Trend Analysis